Haulbase
Start free
Bins

Fuel surcharges on a bin rental: what the law says, and a fairer way to charge for fuel

A bin posted at $250 that comes to $312.50 before tax once a 25% fuel surcharge goes on is not a rare story. Here is what Canadian law says about a mandatory fee on top of a posted price, and a fairer way to charge for the fuel a bin really burns.

Josh Devos Founder, Haulbase
6 min read

What the customer sees

A homeowner reads a bin price: $250 for any size, a week, drop off and pick up included. Then the bill comes. A 25% fuel surcharge adds $62.50 before tax, the dump fee goes on top, and the total comes off the card that held the deposit, often before anyone has looked at it.

It happened to my own father in October, and he kept the bill. The bin was $250. Disposal was $252.07 and the enviro fee $5, for $507.07 in all. Then the 25% fuel surcharge went on all three: $126.77, and $63.02 of it was "fuel" on the landfill's own fee. HST went on the surcharge too. Then a 3% card processing fee went on everything, tax included.

$744.26 came off his card at pickup. The bin, the disposal and the enviro fee with tax come to $578.06. The surcharge and the card fee added $166.20.

Nobody likes that. Since 2022 it has a name in Canadian law, and it is worth every bin yard knowing what that law says.

What the law says

In June 2022 the Competition Act was changed to name drip pricing. Section 74.01(1.1) says that advertising a price that can't be reached, because of fixed charges or fees the buyer has to pay, is a false or misleading representation. The one exception is an amount a government puts on the buyer, like HST.

Canadians should be able to trust that the price they see is the one they pay.

That line is the Competition Bureau's. Its advice to businesses is short: never promote a price that can't be reached, and ask yourself whether a customer will be surprised by extra fees. Its signs of drip pricing, for customers, include a total that isn't shown up front and a price you have to scroll or read the fine print to find.

The case that set the bar

In June 2022 Cineplex started charging a $1.50 online fee on movie tickets and showed it lower on the page, after the ticket price. The Competition Bureau took it to the Competition Tribunal.

In September 2024 the Tribunal ruled that it was drip pricing. It ordered Cineplex to pay over $38.9 million, about what the fee had brought in from June 2022 to December 2023, plus legal costs. In January 2026 the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the ruling.

That was a dollar and a half on a movie ticket. A 25% fuel surcharge on a $250 bin is $62.50.

Is a fuel surcharge on a bin drip pricing?

It turns on whether every customer pays it. If the surcharge goes on every bin, the posted price is one nobody can pay, which is what the rule describes. Writing "fuel surcharge may apply" under the price doesn't change that when, in practice, it always does.

Some charges can't be known ahead. Dump fees billed by weight change with every load. The Bureau notes that a fee that varies can still raise concerns, so post your rate per tonne beside the price and say plainly that it is added.

A charge that only some jobs pay, like a long haul past your area, is a different case, as long as the customer is told the amount before they agree to it.

This is a plain reading of the rule, not legal advice. If you aren't sure about your own price list, the Bureau's guidance is linked below, and a lawyer can tell you for certain.

Fuel goes into the drive, not the days

There is a plainer problem with a percent on the rental. A bin sitting in a driveway burns no fuel. The truck burns it on the drop off, any swap and the pickup, and more of it the further the job is from your yard.

A percent of the rental charges a job ten minutes away the same as one fifty kilometres out. It also charges a two week rental more for fuel than a one week rental, though the truck made the same two trips.

A percent on the disposal is further off again. That's the landfill's own fee for the weight in the bin, and a fuel charge on it is a charge on the landfill's price.

Put fuel where it is spent, in your delivery price. Post the area your flat price covers, then a rate per kilometre past it. When diesel goes up, raise the rate per kilometre. The close customer pays less, the far one pays more, and both see it before they book.

Card fees have their own limit

Outside Quebec, Visa and Mastercard let a business add a fee for paying by credit card, capped at 2.4%. It has to be shown before the customer pays: where they pay, online, at the door and on every receipt. Some card networks don't allow one on debit at all.

A 3% card processing fee is over that cap. Worked out on a total that already has tax in it, it is also a fee on the tax.

What to post

Six things on your price list keep the price a customer sees close to the price they pay.

  • The price of the bin and the days it covers, with any fee every customer pays already inside it.
  • What each extra day costs.
  • Your rate per tonne for disposal, and any tonnes included.
  • The area your price covers, and your rate per kilometre past it.
  • Anything that only some jobs pay, and when it applies.
  • A fee for paying by credit card, if you add one: the percent, at 2.4% or less.

If you were the customer

If a surcharge you never agreed to came off your card, ask the company for an itemized bill first. If it still doesn't add up, call the number on the back of your card and tell them you dispute the charge. If the price you saw advertised left out a fee everyone pays, the Competition Bureau takes complaints on its website. A credit card fee over 2.4% is one to raise with your card company too.

Where Haulbase fits

Haulbase is rental and delivery software built in Nova Scotia for yards in Canada. It is built so the price a customer sees is the price they pay.

  • Delivery is priced from the customer's address by road distance, from your own zones or rate per kilometre, and shown before they book.
  • The total they see before they book lists the rental, the delivery and the tax, line by line.
  • Disposal is billed off the scale ticket at the rate you post, by material if your landfill charges different rates.
  • The bill at return shows every line, so a customer can check it against what they were shown.

It is free for 30 days, with no card. After that it is $47 a month, and Haulbase takes nothing from what your customers pay. Card payments and deposit holds run through your own Stripe account, and Stripe's card fee is separate.

We set your page up with you, from your own price list.

Show customers the whole price before they book

Start free, or send us your price list and we will set your page up with you.